How Agencies Actually Buy Production: The Triple-Bid System

Most clients have no idea how a commercial gets made. They approve a budget, they see a finished spot. Everything in between is opaque. That opacity is expensive, and it's by design.

The commercial production industry built a procurement system in the 1970s that governs how brands buy film work at every budget level. It's called the triple-bid system, and if you're a brand manager, agency producer, or filmmaker trying to understand where you fit in the machine, this is the document you should have read five years ago.

The Pipeline Nobody Explains

Before a camera rolls, a commercial job passes through three distinct hands.

The brand has a budget and a marketing objective. They hire an agency.

The advertising agency has a creative team. They develop a concept, write scripts, build storyboards. When the creative is approved, they don't hire a crew directly. They hire a production company.

The production company has directors on its roster. It hires the crew, builds the budget, manages the shoot, and delivers the finished spot.

That's three layers between the brand's money and the camera. Each layer takes a cut. Each layer adds complexity. And each layer has its own set of priorities that may or may not align with the others.

Most freelancers and even some mid-level producers have never seen this pipeline in full. They know their piece of it. The triple-bid system is what governs how work enters the production company layer, and understanding it changes how you read every commercial budget you'll ever see.

What the Triple Bid Actually Is

When an agency is ready to produce a commercial, they send a bid package to three production companies simultaneously. Each production company proposes a director from its roster. Each director writes a treatment. Each production company builds a full budget using the AICP standardized bid form. All three packages come back to the agency, and the agency picks one.

That's the system. Competitive bids from three independent companies, parallel creative proposals, simultaneous pricing. The agency and client review everything and award the job.

The system exists for reasons that are financial first, creative second.

Financial accountability. When a brand is spending $300,000 to $2,000,000 on production, the client's procurement department wants proof the agency isn't just funneling work to a preferred vendor at inflated prices. Three bids create that paper trail. Research from APR (Advertising Production Resources) shows competitive bidding achieves 11 to 20 percent more in estimate negotiation savings versus single-bid awards. That's why procurement departments mandate it.

Creative options. Three directors interpreting the same brief produce three different solutions. One goes cinematic narrative. One goes documentary-style. One goes high-energy montage. The agency sees options they might not have considered. Sometimes the wild card treatment changes the whole direction.

Built-in redundancy. If the favored director's budget comes in too high, or their treatment misses, the agency has two qualified alternates already vetted.

The AICP Form: The Industry's Universal Language

In 1975, the Association of Independent Commercial Producers introduced the standardized bid form. Before it existed, every production company formatted budgets differently. Comparing three bids was like comparing three invoices written in different languages.

The AICP form created a common language. Section A is always pre-production crew. Section B is always shoot crew. Section I is always equipment rental. Section L is always the director's fee. Sections Q through X, added in the 2019 revision after AICP merged with the post-production trade association AICE, cover editorial, color, sound, and social versioning.

When an agency producer gets three AICP bids back, they can compare crew rates line by line, markup percentages side by side, director fees in the same column. The form makes apples-to-apples comparison possible. That's the whole point.

The production fee, which is the production company's markup on below-the-line costs, sits on the cover page and cascades through the entire document automatically. Industry standard runs 15 to 25 percent. Insurance is another 2.5 to 3 percent. Fringes, meaning payroll taxes and union pension and health contributions on union productions, add another 20 to 35 percent on top of crew labor rates.

By the time those markups stack, the client is paying significantly more than the sum of direct costs. A production with $200,000 in below-the-line costs, with a 25 percent production fee, director's fee, talent, and insurance, can land at a $317,500 production company bid. Add the agency's own commission, typically 10 to 17 percent on top of that, and the client writes a check approaching $365,000.

The math is not hidden on the AICP form. It's all there. Most clients never read it.

The Favored Bid and the Courtesy Bid

Here is the part nobody puts in the press kit: the triple bid is often not a fair fight.

When an agency sends out three bid packages, they frequently already know which director they want. The creative team has a relationship with a director whose reel exactly fits the brief. Or they worked together on the last three spots. Or the director came in for a chemistry meeting six months ago and the creative director has been waiting for the right project to call them.

That director is the favored bid. They may get more detailed feedback on the creative call. They may get informal guidance on the budget range the client expects. They're not given the job, but the odds are strongly in their favor.

The other two directors are often courtesy bids. They're invited to satisfy the competitive requirement. Their treatments are reviewed. Their budgets are compared. If the favored director's treatment disappoints or their budget comes in 30 percent over target, a courtesy bid can become the award. It happens. Industry producers talk about their best work coming from directors who weren't the first choice going in. But the dynamic is what it is.

Signs you're a courtesy bid: you received the brief with unusually tight turnaround. You got minimal access to the creative team. The agency's feedback on the creative call was vague and non-committal. You're being asked to bid on a project that's been "in development" for months.

Signs you're the favored director: the creative team is specific and engaged on the call. You're getting follow-up conversations the other bidders aren't. The EP has inside knowledge of the budget range. The timeline gave you a full week for the treatment.

Neither situation is the agency doing anything wrong. It's the system functioning as it was built. Understanding it means you can work it rather than being confused by it.

The Timeline: Brief to Camera

A national commercial follows a predictable clock.

Day 0: brief goes out to three production companies.

Days 1 to 3: creative calls. Thirty to sixty minutes per director. This is where the agency shows their hand, and the director shows how their mind works.

Days 3 to 10: treatment writing and budget construction. The director develops the creative document. The production company's line producer builds the AICP bid in parallel. Both workstreams run simultaneously.

Days 10 to 12: both documents submitted.

Days 12 to 18: agency reviews all three bids, presents recommendation to client.

Days 18 to 25: client decides, award notification goes out.

Total: three to four weeks from brief to award.

Rush timelines compress that to eight to ten days. They're increasingly common as social content cycles shrink and agencies wait until the last minute for client approvals. Rush timelines disadvantage emerging directors who need more time to write competitive treatments. Established directors, and the production companies behind them, can mobilize faster.

Once awarded, pre-production runs two to four weeks for a standard national spot. Casting, location scouting, the pre-production meeting, crew hiring. Add another week for complex builds. Then production days. Then four to eight weeks of post-production, color, sound, and delivery.

From brief to broadcast, a national commercial typically takes three to four months.

Where Dallas Fits In This System

The national bid process is centered in Los Angeles and New York. That's where the major agencies and the top-tier production companies live. But the system extends to every major market.

DFW sits at the intersection of national and regional production. The market handles regional spots for Texas-based brands, national spots that come south from agency offices in New York or Chicago, and direct-to-brand work from the dense concentration of Fortune 500 headquarters in the Metroplex.

Production costs in Dallas run 20 to 40 percent lower than Los Angeles or New York for identical creative. A production that costs $200,000 in Dallas might cost $275,000 to $350,000 in LA, driven by higher crew rates, more expensive studio rental, and steeper location fees. For national brands with approved budgets benchmarked to coast rates, that differential is margin. For brands that set budgets regionally, it's how more ambitious work gets made at the same price.

GLM operates in this specific position: a production company that understands the national bid process, runs full AICP budgets, and can serve both agency clients running a proper triple bid and direct-to-brand clients who need the same level of process rigor without the agency layer.

What This Means If You're Buying Production

If you're a brand manager or marketing director, read the AICP bid form. Every section. Ask your agency to walk you through the line items. Understand what the production fee covers. Know the difference between above-the-line costs (the director's creative fee, talent, major expenses with their own deal terms) and below-the-line costs (the operational budget the markup is applied to).

If you're going direct to a production company without an agency, the process still applies. You deserve the same level of transparency. A production company that can't show you a properly formatted budget is either inexperienced or hiding something.

If you're a filmmaker or producer trying to break into the agency world, understand that the triple bid is the entry point to national work. Get your reel in front of production company EPs. Build relationships with agency producers. Understand that treatments are the deciding document, and a better treatment beats a better reel more often than people admit.

The system is complex by design. The complexity creates barriers that protect established players. Knowing how it works doesn't tear down those barriers, but it does let you navigate them instead of walking into them blind.

---

GLM operates as a full commercial production company based in Dallas, Texas. The company bids AICP-formatted budgets on agency work, direct-to-brand productions, and regional campaigns across DFW and nationally. For project inquiries: gearedlikeamachine.com.